Tainted Treats

Instant

Bake into a Pie

Instant

Savor

Instant

Witch's Oven

Artifact

Sweettooth Witch

Creature — Human Warlock

Tempting Witch

Creature — Human Warlock

Nocturnal Hunger

Instant

The Battle of Bywater

Sorcery

Spider Food

Sorcery

Taste of Death

Sorcery

Late to Dinner

Sorcery

Feed the Cycle

Instant

Mintstrosity

Creature — Horror

Bumbleflower's Sharepot

Artifact

Experimental Confectioner

Creature — Human Peasant

Cauldron Familiar

Creature — Cat

A-Cauldron Familiar

Creature — Cat

Feast or Famine

Instant

Greta, Sweettooth Scourge

Legendary Creature — Human Warrior

Crumb and Get It

Instant

Insatiable Appetite

Instant

Essence Feed

Sorcery

Food Coma

Enchantment

Shelob's Ambush

Instant

Courier of Comestibles

Creature — Human Citizen

Cirith Ungol Patrol

Creature — Orc Soldier

The Bearded Teakeeper

Legendary Creature — Human Advisor

Common Black Removal

Instant

Bartered Cow

Creature — Ox

Stew the Coneys

Instant

Night of the Sweets' Revenge

Enchantment