Savor

Instant

Shelob, Child of Ungoliant

Legendary Creature — Spider Demon

Scream Puff

Creature — Horror

Sweettooth Witch

Creature — Human Warlock

Second Breakfast

Instant

Night of the Sweets' Revenge

Enchantment

Pippin's Bravery

Instant

Tempting Witch

Creature — Human Warlock

Insatiable Appetite

Instant

Feed the Cauldron

Instant

Crumb and Get It

Instant

Nocturnal Hunger

Instant

Bake into a Pie

Instant

Mintstrosity

Creature — Horror

Greta, Sweettooth Scourge

Legendary Creature — Human Warrior

Provisions Merchant

Creature — Beast Peasant

Tainted Treats

Instant

Lash of Thorns

Instant

Cirith Ungol Patrol

Creature — Orc Soldier

Spider Food

Sorcery

Fortifying Provisions

Enchantment

Savvy Hunter

Creature — Human Warrior

Creeping Crystal Coating

Enchantment — Aura

Bilbo, Fellow Conspirator

Legendary Creature — Halfling Citizen

Experimental Confectioner

Creature — Human Peasant

Heroic Feast

Enchantment

Canyon Crawler

Creature — Spider Beast

Midnight Snack

Enchantment

Hurska Sweet-Tooth

Legendary Creature — Bear

Rapacious Guest

Creature — Halfling Citizen

Tough Cookie

Artifact Creature — Food Golem