---
target_card: Tattered Apparition
mana_cost: "{3}{B}"
type_line: "Creature — Shade"
algorithm: "4096-dimensional Qwen 8B Cosine Similarity over 38,000 Oracle embeddings"
canonical_url: https://avascry.com/similar/tattered-apparition
json_api: https://avascry.com/similar/tattered-apparition.json
---

# Cards Similar & Synergistic to Tattered Apparition

- **Target Card:** [Tattered Apparition](https://avascry.com/printing/tattered-apparition-dmu) (Creature — Shade) `{3}{B}`
- **Algorithm:** 4096-dimensional Qwen 8B Cosine Similarity over 38,000 Oracle embeddings
- **JSON API:** https://avascry.com/similar/tattered-apparition.json

## Top 31 Synergistic Matches

1. [**Drifting Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/drifting-shade-m12) `{3}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
2. [**Dungeon Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/dungeon-shade-tpr) `{3}{B}` — *Creature — Shade Spirit*
3. [**Nightwing Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/nightwing-shade-m14) `{4}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
4. [**Chilling Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/chilling-shade-csp) `{2}{B}` — *Snow Creature — Shade*
5. [**Veiled Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/veiled-shade-grn) `{2}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
6. [**Pit Imp**](https://avascry.com/printing/pit-imp-tmp) `{B}` — *Creature — Imp*
7. [**Looming Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/looming-shade-7ed) `{2}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
8. [**Frozen Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/frozen-shade-30a) `{2}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
9. [**Skyshroud Vampire**](https://avascry.com/printing/skyshroud-vampire-tpr) `{3}{B}{B}` — *Creature — Vampire*
10. [**Dread Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/dread-shade-dom) `{B}{B}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
11. [**Nantuko Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/nantuko-shade-tor) `{B}{B}` — *Creature — Insect Shade*
12. [**Fledgling Imp**](https://avascry.com/printing/fledgling-imp-ody) `{2}{B}` — *Creature — Imp*
13. [**Darklit Gargoyle**](https://avascry.com/printing/darklit-gargoyle-con) `{1}{W}` — *Artifact Creature — Gargoyle*
14. [**Shadowcloak Vampire**](https://avascry.com/printing/shadowcloak-vampire-m15) `{4}{B}` — *Creature — Vampire*
15. [**Bloodied Ghost**](https://avascry.com/printing/bloodied-ghost-plst) `{1}{W/B}{W/B}` — *Creature — Spirit*
16. [**Grimclaw Bats**](https://avascry.com/printing/grimclaw-bats-dst) `{1}{B}` — *Creature — Bat*
17. [**Keening Banshee**](https://avascry.com/printing/keening-banshee-rav) `{2}{B}{B}` — *Creature — Spirit*
18. [**Roofstalker Wight**](https://avascry.com/printing/roofstalker-wight-clu) `{1}{B}` — *Creature — Zombie*
19. [**Perilous Shadow**](https://avascry.com/printing/perilous-shadow-rtr) `{2}{B}{B}` — *Creature — Insect Shade*
20. [**Feral Shadow**](https://avascry.com/printing/feral-shadow-6ed) `{2}{B}` — *Creature — Nightstalker*
21. [**Hoar Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/hoar-shade-ice) `{3}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
22. [**Hyalopterous Lemure**](https://avascry.com/printing/hyalopterous-lemure-me1) `{4}{B}` — *Creature — Spirit*
23. [**Skirge Familiar**](https://avascry.com/printing/skirge-familiar-mh2) `{4}{B}` — *Creature — Phyrexian Imp*
24. [**Misshapen Fiend**](https://avascry.com/printing/misshapen-fiend-mmq) `{1}{B}` — *Creature — Horror Mercenary*
25. [**Fetid Horror**](https://avascry.com/printing/fetid-horror-mir) `{3}{B}` — *Creature — Shade Horror*
26. [**Nakaya Shade**](https://avascry.com/printing/nakaya-shade-pcy) `{1}{B}` — *Creature — Shade*
27. [**Battlefield Percher**](https://avascry.com/printing/battlefield-percher-nem) `{3}{B}{B}` — *Creature — Bird*
28. [**Vampire Bats**](https://avascry.com/printing/vampire-bats-10e) `{B}` — *Creature — Bat*
29. [**Balshan Collaborator**](https://avascry.com/printing/balshan-collaborator-tor) `{3}{U}` — *Creature — Bird Soldier*
30. [**Moaning Spirit**](https://avascry.com/printing/moaning-spirit-p02) `{2}{B}` — *Creature — Spirit*
31. [**Abyssal Specter**](https://avascry.com/printing/abyssal-specter-dvd) `{2}{B}{B}` — *Creature — Specter*